Skip to content
CHESTNO.BG

What's Hot

Positive mind

“I Lie to You Because I Cannot Tell You the Truth”…

How does the liar turn your reaction into his own justification?
“I lie to you because I can’t tell you the truth”…

“I lie to you because I can’t tell you the truth”…

AUTHOR: Ruslana PETROVA

When a lie is exposed, the problem seems obvious. When the lies are repeated and the reaction of the person who was deceived ultimately becomes the thing at fault, the relationship falls into a far more complicated psychological trap.

There is one sentence that can turn the entire conversation upside down:

“I lie to you because I can’t tell you the truth. Look at how you react.”

At first glance, it even seems logical.

No one likes arguments. People avoid conflict. They fear rejection, separation, accusations and consequences. Sometimes they keep quiet because the truth is unpleasant.

But what happens when this is no longer an isolated case?

When the pattern is always the same?

Lie. Discovery. Promise. New lie. New discovery.

And finally:

“You make me lie to you.”

This is precisely where the problem is no longer just the untruth.

The problem is that cause and effect begin to switch places.

First, they lie to you. Then your reaction becomes evidence against you

Imagine a relationship in which one partner repeatedly discovers that what the other has said does not correspond to reality.

At first, they ask questions. Then they begin to doubt. After a while, they check. Eventually, they may react explosively at the first sign of a discrepancy.

And that is exactly when the argument comes:

“That’s why I don’t tell you the truth.”

It creates an almost perfect closed circle…

The lie creates distrust. Distrust creates tension. Tension provokes stronger reactions. And those reactions are then used as an excuse for the next lie.

Research does indeed show a connection between concealment and the erosion of trust. A long term study of 199 newlywed couples found that perceived concealment by a partner was associated with declining trust and satisfaction and with increasing conflict over time.

This does not mean that every strong reaction is justified.

It means something else:

We cannot analyze the reaction as if everything that happened before it had never happened.

“I’m afraid of your reaction” may be true

And this is where the important part comes in.

Not everyone who lies out of fear of conflict is a cold blooded manipulator. Sometimes the fear is completely real.

Some people have difficulty coping with confrontation. There are relationships in which communication has become so toxic that an unpleasant truth almost guarantees an explosion. There are partners who humiliate, punish, threaten or use the other person’s confessions against them.

Research on intimate relationships shows that a strong orientation toward avoidance may be associated with more negative communication during conflict. In a study of 365 couples, people with stronger avoidance goals maintained high levels of negative communication during conflict and reacted more strongly to their partner’s negative behavior.

Therefore:

“I was afraid to tell you” may be a genuine explanation.

But an explanation and an excuse are not the same thing. Fear may explain why someone wanted to avoid the truth. It does not automatically make the other person the author of the lie.

There is a huge difference between “I’m afraid to tell you” and “You make me lie”

The first sentence accepts responsibility.

“We have a problem. I’m afraid of the way we talk to each other.”

The second shifts it.

“My action is actually the result of your behavior.”

This distinction is crucial. Two people can have a problem at the same time. One may be lying. The other may be reacting destructively. One does not cancel out the other.

Responsibility for the reaction belongs to the person reacting. Responsibility for the lie belongs to the person who chose to lie.

Mature relationships begin where both people can say these two sentences at the same time, without one problem being used as an indulgence for the other.

The most serious consequence of constant lying is not the lie itself

One lie shatters a specific fact. Repeated lying shatters something much bigger:

the assumption that the words of the person beside you mean something.

After a while, you no longer check only the big stories.

You start noticing the details…

The time.

The date.

Who was where.

Why yesterday the version was one thing and today it is another.

Why one detail has suddenly changed.

And gradually, intimacy turns into an investigation…

This is one of the reasons trust is so fundamental to relationships. A study of 329 married participants found a connection between a lack of trust, checking a partner’s phone and problems such as conflict, emotional instability and intentions to separate. The authors do not prove that one inevitably causes the other, but they show how easily distrust and checking can become part of the same destructive dynamic.

And then something paradoxical happens.

The person who checks hears:

“You have no trust in me whatsoever.”

It may be true. But the question remains:

What happened to that trust?

Trust is not an unlimited line of credit

We often talk about trust as though it were a moral obligation.

“If you love me, you have to trust me.”

NO!

Trust does not mean voluntarily switching off your ability to recognize reality. It is built through predictability. You say something, and it turns out to be true. You promise something, and your behavior confirms it. You make a mistake, and you admit it before someone shows you the evidence.

That is how words gradually acquire weight. And in exactly the same way, they can lose it.

A new experimental study on deception and trust shows something particularly interesting: a lie from someone close can lead to a greater decline in trust than deception by a stranger. Closeness clearly does not make us immune to lies. It can increase their cost.

Because we expect little from a stranger. From the person beside us, we expect more.

A lie “to avoid an argument” has one problem: the argument simply comes later

This is perhaps the most tempting form of self deception.

“I won’t tell her or him because there will be a problem.”

“I’ll keep it to myself so I don’t hurt him or her.”

“I’ll give a different version so there won’t be an argument.”

In the short term, the strategy is brilliant.

There is no conflict.

There are no consequences.

There is no unpleasant conversation.

Except that the initial problem has not disappeared.

It has simply been joined by another…

The deception.

When the truth comes out, the partner is no longer reacting only to what happened. They are also reacting to the fact that, for a certain period of time, they lived in a version of reality that another person had deliberately provided.

That is why the argument after a lie is exposed often seems “too big” compared with the specific occasion. Because the occasion is no longer just the occasion. It carries all the previous instances with it.

And then the most dangerous question begins: “What if the problem is actually me?”

Self reflection is healthy. A person should be able to ask whether they are excessively jealous. Whether they are controlling. Whether they shout. Whether they punish with silence. Whether they make confession impossible.

But there is a huge difference between:

“I have behavior that I need to change”

and:

“My behavior makes another person have no choice but to lie to me.”

The second removes their responsibility. And a choice almost always exists.

The unpleasant truth can be told.

A boundary can be set.

A different way of communicating can be requested.

The conversation can be ended.

The relationship can even be ended.

Lying is also a choice…

The truth has a price. That is precisely why we sometimes choose to lie

Telling the truth does not guarantee a happy ending.

The other person may get angry.

They may be disappointed.

They may set a boundary.

They may leave.

And this is precisely where one of the most unpleasant functions of lying lies. Sometimes, through it, a person does not merely avoid conflict. They try to control the information on the basis of which the other person will make a decision.

And that changes everything…

Because if the truth would make your partner choose differently, hiding it does not merely protect you from their reaction. It deprives them of the opportunity to respond to reality as it is.

“I will never lie to you again” does not fix anything by itself

After the revelation, the vow often follows.

The promise.

The apology.

Sometimes, the tears.

And they may be completely sincere at the moment they are shed. But trust has the unpleasant quality of caring very little about the drama. It looks at the behavior that follows.

Research on relationship recovery after deception is revealed shows a link between constructive relationship-repair strategies and a subsequent increase in trust and closeness.

That is why the real question is not:

“How convincingly did you promise?”

But:

“What did you do differently after making the promise?”

And even more importantly:

Did you voluntarily tell the next uncomfortable truth, or did it once again have to be discovered?

Can there once again be a safe environment for the truth?

Yes.

But it cannot be built solely by the person who has already been lied to. One person has a responsibility to be able to hear an unpleasant truth without humiliation, threats or psychological punishment. The other has a responsibility to tell the truth, including when it may cost them something.

That is the two-sided contract.

Not:

“First trust me unconditionally, and then I will start being honest.”

Because that requires wounded trust to magically recover first, so that the behavior that is supposed to restore it can emerge. The absurdity is obvious…

At some point, the question is no longer, “Why does this person lie to me?”

Psychology can offer many possible answers.

Fear of conflict.

Shame.

A desire for approval.

Avoiding consequences.

Fear of loss.

Protecting one’s self-image.

Habit.

Self-interest.

But understanding someone’s reason does not create an obligation to live indefinitely with its consequences. That is why perhaps the most important question in relationships like these is not:

“Why does this person keep lying to me?”

But:

“What kind of person am I becoming as I constantly try to discover the truth?”

Am I at peace?

Or am I always on guard?

Do I trust the words?

Or do I check the facts?

Do I talk to my partner?

Or do I collect evidence?

Because there comes a point when the argument is no longer about the specific lie. It is about the very reality of the relationship. And then one painfully simple question remains:

Are there still two people trying to rebuild trust, or is there one who continues to lie and another who is simply becoming better and better at catching them?

Love can survive mistakes.

It can survive difficult truths.

Sometimes it even survives betrayals.

But it struggles to survive where the truth must constantly be sought out.

Advertisement

Comments

Leave a Reply